Contact Us

2 East Main Street

Babylon NY 11702







1.866.669.0365 Toll Free


Monday - Friday 

8:30 am to 5:00 pm


Weekends and evenings

by Appointment


About Norton and Siegel, Inc.

Norton and Siegel, Inc. is located in the heart of Babylon Village, on the beautiful South Shore of Long Island.

Since it first opened in Babylon in 1892, Norton and Siegel has been dedicated to providing all customers with personal, competitive service. Using the most current technology and employing dedicated workers, this agency combines the best of both modern and traditional business.

As an independent agency, we are dedicated to serving you. We represent several leading insurance companies rather than any single provider. Therefore, we have the ability to continually monitor the marketplace and offer you the best possible rates. Our goal is to provide you the highest level of customer service and dedicate our resources to meet your needs and earn your trust. Our success is based on your continued satisfaction.

We invite you to contact our office at the address and phone numbers below.  We guarantee your needs will be addressed, phone calls returned, and coverage issues responded to, and claim matters will be addressed promptly!

Aaron J. Stein, CPCU, is the owner of our agency. Aaron, who has lived in Babylon his whole life, represents the third generation of family members to own the agency. Aaron earned his Bachelor’s of Science in Business Management from SUNY Old Westbury; he then went on to obtain his professional designations as a Certified Financial Planner and Charter Property Casualty Underwriter.

Aaron lives in Babylon with his wife of almost 40 years, Mary Ann. They have two grown children and one grandchild. He is a past District Governor for Rotary, 15 year president of the board of the Babylon Village Youth Project, and many other community activities.

Aaron's Avatar

Lisa Suger - Lisa is the most senior member of the staff after Aaron. She has over 25 years of experience in insurance and almost 20 years with our office. She is knowledgable on all forms of Personal insurance protection and will help you come up with an insurance program that gives you peace of mind at a fair price. Lisa is very proud of her daughter who is a newly minted nurse.

Kelly Holden - Kelly is another expert in all types of Personal insurance but in addition she is our chief office flood insurance geek as well as our 'pit bull' of problem solving. When something is incorrect and it's not getting fixed, she is known to go into 'Beast Mode' on behalf of our customers. She WILL get the issue fixed. Kelly has been with us over 10 years and enjoys Karaoke and visiting her family in South Carolina.

Jerry Cohen - Jerry is our Life, Health and Benefits manager. He has over 30 years experience and is extremely knowledgeable. He has a degree in Social Work and uses his training to help clients reach a comfort level with their coverages. Jerry is married to Teri and they are very proud of their grown son and daughter who are busy making lives for themselves.

Zoey - Zoey is Jerry's Maltese and has become our office mascot. Zoey keeps us company several days a week. When she found out she was going to be included on our page, her response was 'woof woof woof, bark whine' and then she did something messy on the floor. Fortunately she has Jerry along to clean such things up.

More Flood Insurance Sites

Our State-Specific

Flood Insurance Sites





© 2018 by Norton and Siegel, Inc. Created with Wix.com     >>>     Call us: 631.669.0365

  • Facebook Basic
  • Our Youtube Page
  • Aaron's LinkedIn Profile